---

Like many people, I have often asked myself:
Why do we have to endure so much suffering?

Does everything that happens to us have some deeper meaning?
Is pain always a lesson?
And could suffering perhaps be avoided if we simply lived the “right” way?

Over time, I have heard many different answers to these questions.

Some spiritual people say:
It is your karma.

Others claim that our soul chose certain experiences before we were born so that we could grow through them.

And in some Christian circles, you hear:

You sinned. That is why this is happening to you.

Or:

God is allowing this because you need to learn something.

In the end, many of these ideas lead to the same message:

If you are suffering, it must somehow be your fault.
And that is exactly where I have a problem.
Because sometimes it is not only wrong, but cruel, to tell someone that they caused their own suffering
when no one truly knows their story.

---

Does Suffering Always Have a Reason?

The Bible tells the story of a man who brings this question into especially sharp focus:

Job.

Job is described as upright and God-fearing.
And yet he loses almost everything.

His family.
His possessions.
His health.
His sense of security.

If suffering were always the direct result of personal failure, Job’s story would have to look very different.

But it does not.

Without cause.

At least as far as Job’s guilt is concerned, the text gives a clear answer:

He is not suffering because he failed morally.
He is not suffering because he “believed too little.”
He is not suffering because he deserved God’s anger.

The suffering strikes him — without the text placing the blame on him.
And there can be something deeply freeing in that.

---

“Without Cause” Can Also Be an Acquittal

At first, the words “without cause” can sound frightening, almost arbitrary.
But for Job, they also mean:

You are not to blame.

That matters. Because we human beings are incredibly quick to search for causes.

When someone suffers, we want to know why.

What did they do?
What could they have prevented?
Which wrong decision led to this?

Perhaps that even comforts us. Because as long as we believe suffering must always be deserved or caused, we can tell ourselves:

If I do everything right, this will not happen to me.

But life is not that tidy.

People become ill.
Others are betrayed.
Accidents happen.
Natural disasters strike people who did nothing to cause them.
Other people act unjustly, selfishly, or cruelly.
Sometimes suffering grows out of a long chain of circumstances that no one fully controls.

Not every suffering carries a hidden message.

Not every suffering is a test or punishment.

Sometimes there is no deeper reason.
And that can be an acquittal.

Be Careful with Simple Answers to Someone Else’s Suffering

Job’s friends also want to explain why all of this is happening to him.

They are convinced:

You must have done something.

Perhaps you know phrases like these:

“The universe is trying to show you something.”
“You attract what you put out.”
“God is correcting you.”
“You just need to understand what your lesson is.”

Statements like these can be brutal.
Because suddenly, a person has to carry not only their suffering, but also the blame for it.
And yet outsiders often have no real idea what actually happened.
Compassion does not always need an explanation.

Sometimes a person simply needs someone who says:

I see that this hurts.

And then stays.

---

A Good Life Does Not Protect Us from Everything

Perhaps this raises the question:

If living a good life does not protect me from suffering, why should I make the effort at all?

Because the way we live and the relationships we build can still carry us.

Not like a magical shield, but like a net.

People with whom we have built healthy relationships can catch us when we fall.
A clear sense of who we are can help us not to lose ourselves.
And when we know that we did not cause a situation ourselves, we do not have to break under the added weight of false guilt.

Job loses almost everything.

But he does not completely lose himself.

---

Suffering Was Not the Goal

Later, the Letter of James looks back to Job:

I find that important, because the suffering itself is not glorified.
The focus shifts to what comes afterwards.

To the end of suffering.
To compassion.
To restoration.

Job’s story does not say:

Suffering is beautiful.

Nor does it say:

You should be grateful for it.

---

Suffering Is Not a Spiritual Achievement

There is a saying:

Perhaps that sentence helps some people. But it can also be deeply hurtful.

Because once again, suffering is automatically given a purpose.

As though every pain had to be sent by God so that we would finally learn something.

But suffering does not automatically make people better.

Some become softer.
Others harder.
Some grow through it.
Others break down first.

And both are human.

Nor am I convinced by the idea that we need suffering in order to appreciate what is good.

There are people who live gratefully without first having gone through hell.

And if the biblical hope of a world without suffering is true, such a world would otherwise have to be full of ungrateful people.

That does not make much sense.

You Do Not Have to Romanticise Your Suffering

Paul writes:

For me, this does not mean:
Your suffering is not really that bad.

Quite the opposite.

Suffering is allowed to be heavy.
It is allowed to feel unbearable.
You are allowed to cry.
You are allowed to be angry.
You are allowed to say:

I do not want this.

Hope does not mean making pain smaller.

---

And What If I Contributed to My Own Suffering?

Of course, there are situations in which our own decisions have consequences.

Perhaps we hurt someone.
Perhaps we ignored warning signs.
Perhaps we did something that later harmed us as well.

Then we are allowed to look at it honestly.

To take responsibility.
To change something.
To apologise.
To act differently next time.

But insight is not the same as self-condemnation.

You do not have to punish yourself forever just because you once made the wrong decision.

A mistake does not have to become your identity.

---

Is God on My Side If He Does Not Prevent My Suffering?

Perhaps this is one of the hardest questions of all.

Because we are often offered only two extremes.

Either God is the punishing judge who sends suffering.

Or faith is softened so much that it almost sounds as though real trust should transform every pain into peace.

Job fits neither picture.

He suffers.
He laments.
He does not understand.
He argues back.

And yet he is not condemned for refusing to pretend that his suffering is beautiful.

Quite the opposite:

---

God Does Not Have to Be Behind Every Pain

I do not believe that we should attribute every tragedy directly to God.
This world is full of freedom, chance, human choices, physical limitations, and events beyond our control.
Suffering exists.

But that does not automatically mean:

God sent it.

And God’s presence does not mean that every situation changes immediately either.

Sometimes help comes through people.

Through someone who stays.
Through a hand.
Through a sentence.

Through that quiet inner feeling:

Do not give up yet.

---

Acceptance Does Not Mean Approval

Job says:

I would not understand this as an invitation to pretend that suffering is beautiful.
Acceptance means something else.

It means:

This is my reality right now.

I do not have to love it.
I do not have to think it is fair.
I do not have to discover some higher meaning in it.

But I can stop fighting against the fact that, for now, it exists.

And from that, movement can eventually begin again.

---

My Conclusion